Long-Tail vs. Short-Tail Keywords: Which Should You Use for Your Print-on-Demand Book?
When it comes to increasing the visibility of your book in a crowded marketplace, we ought to think strategically about the meta-data, specifically the keywords, that we use to represent the content of the book. Think of this article as the “level-up” to our earlier entry on choosing keywords. In this piece, we’ll be taking a closer look at the distinct roles played by short-tail and long-tail keywords, and we’ll examine their impact across platforms like Amazon, IngramSpark, and even niche marketplaces like Etsy. Unpacking the function of keywords will help you make decisions that support your book’s visibility, so do not settle on the keywords for your print on demand book until you read what’s coming up! Your future metadata will thank you.
What Are Short-Tail Keywords?
Short-tail keywords are broad, one-to two-word terms such as:
“fantasy novel”
“nutrition”
“mystery book”
“self-help”
These are high-volume, highly competitive search terms. They’re the crowded highways of book discovery. But as we know, with an abundance of traffic comes a delay in getting [your book] where you need to be!
So why bother with short-tail keywords, then? If they’re too broad to help your book stand out in a crowded market place, how are they useful?
What they’re good for:
Clarifying your book’s general genre. While “romance” might be too broad, consider how short-tail keywords like “vampire romance” pack in additional and specific data, drawing in readers of romance, supernatural, and those who want to relive the vampire-crazy days of the early 2000s.
Helping platforms understand where your book belongs (category placement). Using the example above, your book on vampire romance would likely fall into categories related to romance and supernatural, which is exactly where your target audience will be looking for your book.
Some instances where short-tail keywords cannot be relied upon to boost your book’s visibility include reaching an especially niche audience or targeting clear buyer intent.
To ensure your search terms are narrowed enough to meet your readers in these circumstances, it would be prudent to employ some long-tail keywords.
What Are Long-Tail Keywords?
Long-tail keywords are three to seven word phrases that narrow the search into a specific reader’s needs. Example phrases include:
“cozy mystery set in small towns”
“slow cooker recipes for beginners”
“guided productivity journal for entrepreneurs”
“affirmations for teenage girls”
These terms attract less search volume but the people who do search them are far more likely to click, preview, and buy.
What they’re good for:
Capturing ready-to-buy readers.
Differentiating your book in competitive spaces.
Serving niche categories, micro-genres, and special interests.
And importantly, print-on-demand platforms like Amazon KDP or IngramSpark increasingly reward relevancy and specificity, and that’s all long-tail territory.
How Different Keyword Types Perform on Print-on-Demand Platforms
Every platform handles keywords slightly differently, so the right mix depends on where you publish.
Amazon KDP, Ingram Spark and Libraries
Amazon’s algorithm thrives on relevance signals and buyer behaviour. Long-tail terms often outperform short-tail terms because they attract precise audiences. However, short-tail terms still matter for genre and filter placement.
IngramSpark and other distribution networks, like those in use at your local library, need a combination of short-tail terms (for general classification) and long-tail terms (for more accurate positioning) in order to maintain clarity and structure.
Etsy & Niche Marketplaces
Long-tail wins almost all the time. Shoppers use conversational search and intent-based phrasing, which cannot be captured by short-tail keywords.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Yes. Keywords can and should be updated over time. Many authors refresh them every 2–3 months based on sales data, trends, or seasonal rotation.
-
Not always. They’re excellent for matching buyer intent, but short-tail keywords are still important for helping retailers classify your book correctly.
-
You can be inspired by trends, but avoid copying unique or branded phrases. Focus on the language readers use—not another author’s exact wording.
-
Yes, naturally and sparingly. Descriptions help algorithms understand relevance, but avoid stuffing or awkward phrasing.
-
For most POD authors, four to five long-tail phrases plus one to two short-tails provides a strong balance.
How to Combine Short-Tail and Long-Tail Keywords Effectively
Establishing metadata harmony looks something like this:
Two short-tails to establish your genre or topic.
Four to five long-tails to capture reader intent and highlight your niche.
Here are sample balanced keyword sets for fiction and non-fiction books:
Fiction Book:
romance
contemporary romance
small-town second-chance romance
love story about rebuilding trust
clean romance with mature characters
heartwarming family-centered romance plot
Non-fiction Book:
budgeting
personal finance
zero-based budgeting workbook
budgeting strategies for young adults
household expense tracker for beginners
financial planning guide for new graduates
Common Keyword Mistakes to Avoid
Using only broad, high-competition short-tails.
Creating long-tail phrases so vague or personal that they match no existing search.
Repeating variations of the same phrase (“fantasy dragons,” “dragon fantasy,” “book about dragons”).
Ignoring competitor positioning.
Keyword stuffing your title or description with awkward phrasing.
Clean, natural, reader-friendly metadata always wins.
How Foglio Helps Authors Build Strong Keyword Strategy
If you’d like a professional eye on your keyword strategy, Foglio offers metadata and POD optimization services tailored to your goals. Choosing keywords is no longer about guessing or throwing phrases at a wall. Understanding the difference between short-tail and long-tail keywords gives you a clear framework for choosing high-performing metadata. The right mix helps platforms understand your book, ensures algorithms place it correctly, and most importantly helps the right readers discover it.
Foglio helps authors refine metadata using a combination of research, competitive analysis, and platform-specific best practices. Our work includes full keyword audits for KDP and IngramSpark, recommendations for title and subtitle alignment, and refreshing strategies for keywords after launch. We’d be happy to help you shape a keyword list that boosts your book’s visibility. You bring the manuscript; we’ll help readers find it!
